Open Captions vs Closed Captions: Differences and When to Use Each
Open captions are burned into the video and always show; closed captions are a separate file viewers can turn on and off. What each is good for, what WCAG says, and which to use on YouTube, TikTok, Reels and your own site.
Caption Generator Research · Updated
Short answer: Open captions are part of the picture. They're burned into the video, so they always show and look the same everywhere. Closed captions are a separate text track, usually an SRT or VTT file, that viewers can turn on or off. For short videos in social feeds, open captions are the safer bet because they show even when the app doesn't load a caption file. For YouTube, course platforms and your own website, closed captions are better because viewers control them and you can add more languages. Many videos use both.
The difference at a glance
The W3C's accessibility team defines closed captions as captions that "can be hidden or shown by people watching the video," and open captions as captions that "are always displayed and cannot be turned off" (W3C WAI).
| Open captions (burned in) | Closed captions (SRT, VTT) | |
|---|---|---|
| Can viewers turn them off? | No | Yes |
| Where they live | In the video pixels | A separate file or track |
| Look and position | Exactly as you designed them | Set by the player, and often by the viewer |
| Works on any app or player | Yes, they're part of the video | Only where the platform accepts caption files |
| Animated, word-by-word styles | Yes | No, players show plain text |
| More than one language | One per video file | Many tracks on one video |
| Editing after publishing | Re-export and re-upload | Replace the file |
"Burned-in", "hardcoded" and "open" captions all mean the same thing. "Soft" subtitles and "sidecar" files are closed captions.
What accessibility rules say
Both kinds count. WCAG 2.2 success criterion 1.2.2 (level A) requires captions for prerecorded audio in synchronized media, and lists both "providing open (always visible) captions" (technique G93) and closed captions (G87) as sufficient ways to meet it (W3C, Understanding SC 1.2.2). The same page adds a requirement that applies to burned-in captions in particular: captions "should not obscure or obstruct relevant information in the video."
Closed captions have one accessibility advantage: some players let viewers change the text size, colors and position (W3C WAI). Someone with low vision can make closed captions bigger. They can't do that with open captions, so if you burn them in, make them large and high-contrast to start with.
Captions also include more than speech. Under WCAG, captions cover the non-speech audio needed to follow the video too, such as sound effects, music and who is speaking (W3C).
When to use open captions
- Short-form feeds: TikTok, Reels, Shorts, LinkedIn and X. Videos autoplay in the feed, often muted, and the viewer decides in a second or two whether to keep watching. Burned-in captions are already on screen; closed captions only show if the app supports them and the viewer has them on. (For the real numbers on muted viewing, see our sound-off video statistics.)
- Styled, word-by-word captions. The bold, animated captions common on short-form video only exist as open captions. Players draw closed captions as plain text.
- Ads and clips that get reposted. Captions burned into the file survive downloads, reposts and screen recordings. A separate caption file doesn't travel with the video.
Keep burned-in captions clear of the app's buttons and description. Our TikTok safe zone checker and Instagram Reels safe zone checker show where they'll be covered.
When to use closed captions
- YouTube. YouTube accepts caption files in many formats, including SubRip (.srt) and WebVTT (.vtt) (YouTube Help). Viewers can switch them on and off, and you can upload more than one language.
- Your website or course platform. HTML video takes a VTT file through a
<track>element, which is the closed-caption technique WCAG lists as H95 (W3C). Most course platforms and video hosts take SRT or VTT too. - Long videos and several languages. A lecture, webinar or interview is easier to watch with captions the viewer controls, and one video can carry a caption file per language.
- Videos that already have text on screen. If the frame is busy with slides or graphics, captions the viewer can turn off avoid covering them.
When to use both
For most creators, the answer is both: burn styled captions into the short version for social, and upload an SRT or VTT file with the long version on YouTube or your site. A caption tool that makes one from the other saves you transcribing twice.
Captions vs subtitles
The W3C notes that "captions" and "subtitles" are used for the same thing in different parts of the world (W3C WAI). Strictly, captions are in the same language as the audio and include sounds and speaker names, while subtitles are a translation for viewers who can hear but don't speak the language. In the UK and much of Europe, "subtitles" covers both.
How to make each one
With Caption Generator, you transcribe once and can export both:
- Open captions: pick a style, then export an MP4 with the captions burned in, sized for 9:16, 1:1, 4:5 or 16:9. Or export the captions alone as a transparent overlay to place over your footage in your editor.
- Closed captions: download the SRT or VTT file, free on every plan, and upload it to YouTube, your site or your course platform.
Your video stays in your browser either way. Only a compressed audio track is sent for transcription.
Sources
We opened every source linked here on 1 November 2026.
Related: SRT generator, VTT generator, add subtitles to a YouTube video and best fonts for captions.
Cite this report
Free to use with a link back. Each figure above links to its original source.
Caption Generator Research, "Open Captions vs Closed Captions: Differences and When to Use Each," updated November 2026, https://captiongenerator.co/reports/open-vs-closed-captions
<a href="https://captiongenerator.co/reports/open-vs-closed-captions">Open Captions vs Closed Captions: Differences and When to Use Each</a>